Haven't played many of those games. But I think SW would win by default simply due to having more games.Darksi4190 wrote:Just do something like a general SW games vs. ST games with multiple catagoriesRogueIce wrote:So just as a joke, I've been considering making a "Star Wars vs Star Trek: MMO Edition" pitting TOR against STO.
But I don't know if that's considered trolling or not.
FPS: Elite Force I and II vs. Republic Commando and Battlefront (SW wins due to more games of higher quality)
Starfleet Command and Bridge Commander falls under strategy? Why wouldn't it fall under simulators?Strategy: Armada I and II, Starfleet Command, Bridge Commander, and lots of others vs. Rebellion, Galactic Battlegrounds, and Empire at War (ST wins because Galactic Battlegrounds drags down the SW quality average)
Birth of the Federation though is better than Rebellion. Rebellion has some really terrible game design problems. While Birth of the Federation comes across a little like a MoO sequel it still succeeded at what it was trying to do.
Never played the other entries for SW. I didn't like Armada though.
I'd put Starfleet Command here, and Bridge Commander, and also the Academy games even though I never played them.Flight Sims: X-wing series, Rogue Squadron series, and Starfighter series Vs. Um, Star Trek Invasion? (SW wins hardcore)
I don't know who'd win, but I'd enjoy playing all the entries.
It had adventure games though, which is kinda sorta equivalent. A Final Unity and the old TOS games would be competitive with KotOR 1 and 2. Especially how 1 sucks and 2 is awesome. A Final Unity in particular comes across like an extended episode of the series. One of these days that game is gonna go on sale on GoG and I will be happy.RPGs: Kotor I and II vs. ok I don't think ST has any RPG games (SW wins by default)
I'd say STO wins because it does the free-to-play thing a lot better than what I understand TOR does. STO also has fun space combat, some great storytelling, and ok ground combat.MMOs: Star Trek Online vs. TOR and Galaxies (Close, but ST might win due to post-NGE galaxies being a festering pile of rancor shit)
I'd like to play TOR at some point, but I'm not really there yet. A lot of the things I heard about TOR really rubbed me the wrong way. STO seems like a game that's growing, which is not the impression I get from TOR.